Edmonton ranks as nation’s economic champ — save for Calgary
Thursday, November 30th, 2006Edmonton’s fast-growing regional economy continues to outstrip the performance of every other major Canadian city except one: Calgary.
Those are the findings of CIBC World Markets’ latest Metropolitan Economic Activity Index, which shows Edmonton holding down second spot behind its perennial provincial rival.
CIBC’s index — which measures the rate of positive economic momentum in Canada’s 25 largest urban centres by tracking nine key local indicators — shows that Edmonton’s red-hot economy continues to accelerate.
Since the spring, Edmonton has leapfrogged seven major Canadian cities in CIBC’s semi-annual rankings, including Ottawa-Gatineau, Toronto, Vancouver, Hamilton, Kitchener, Kingston and Victoria.
And with energy prices expected to remain robust, Edmonton is likely to remain near the top of the national rankings in the year ahead.
“To what extent Edmonton will be able to maintain its position as number two is very difficult to predict, but I think it will be right up there,” says CIBC economist Benjamin Tal, the report’s author.
“I think in 2007 we’ll continue to see strong momentum in both Calgary and Edmonton, and less momentum in Toronto and Ottawa. So it’s not just that Edmonton, in absolute terms, will be great. It’s that these other cities may not do as well,” he says.
Vancouver is also expected to experience more sluggish growth in 2007, Tal predicts, as West Coast real estate activity slows in response to sky-high house prices and reduced affordability.
Vancouver and Toronto tied for fourth spot in CIBC’s latest rankings, with a composite index score of 21.9. That’s a hair behind Ottawa-Gatineau, and comfortably ahead of both Montreal and Victoria.
Top-ranked Calgary easily led the nation with an index score of 33.5. Runner-up Edmonton scored 22.2, and Ottawa-Gatineau came third, at 22.0. Hamilton, Sherbrooke and Quebec City round out the top-10 rankings, with Thunder Bay, Regina and Sudbury bringing up the rear.
“I think Vancouver will continue to do relatively well because of the 2010 (Winter) Olympics,” says Tal. “At the same time, Vancouver is becoming extremely expensive.
” One of the reasons it has been losing momentum is the slowing housing market. I think it will get worse in 2007, and that will limit growth.”
CIBC’s index scores reflect nine key variables, including population growth rates, employment levels, personal and business bankruptcy rates, housing starts, MLS (Multiple Listing Service) housing resale levels and non-residential building permits, among other things.
Calgary led the nation in population and employment growth for the latest period, while posting the country’s lowest unemployment rate.
Edmonton’s lofty ranking reflects its rapid population growth as well as its low unemployment rate and robust housing market.
Ottawa-Gatineau topped CIBC’s rankings in the previous survey, slightly ahead of Calgary. Edmonton held down ninth spot.
CIBC’s upbeat outlook for Alberta’s two major cities is echoed by Warren Jestin, Scotiabank Group’s chief economist, who was in Edmonton Wednesday. Jestin expects Alberta to comfortably lead the nation again in 2007, with economic growth pegged at nearly five per cent.
As it has in 2005, British Columbia is expected to hold down second spot, with growth approaching four per cent, while Ontario and Quebec struggle to eke out growth rates of about two percent.
“Substantial regional performance differentials will persist during 2007 as energy and industrial commodity markets are driven by burgeoning Asian demand, with China growing by close to 10 per cent,” Jestin writes in his report.
“The commodity-related boost to incomes and job creation will keep Alberta and B.C. on the fast track and at the top of the provincial population growth charts.” he adds.
“These two provinces, which together match Quebec in population and exceed its GDP (gross domestic product) by more than 40 per cent, will probably grow by nearly twice the pace recorded in Ontario, Quebec and the Maritimes.”
Geez, we’re getting popular. With the Edmonton region’s economy on wheels, the city is being courted as never before by visiting business groups.
Last week, Sandra Pupatello, Ontario’s minister of economic development and trade, led a three-day visit to town involving some 30 Eastern manufacturers, all of whom are eager to get in on the action in Alberta’s booming oilsands.
Next week, Vancouver Island’s Comox Valley Economic Development Society will head a blitz of the city from Dec. 6 through Dec. 8, involving 45 business leaders, realtors and tourism reps.
The visit is aimed at boosting tourism and business ties between Edmonton and the Vancouver Island community, while highlighting WestJet’s new direct service to Comox Valley International Airport.